The United States placed Burma, Uzbekistan, Sudan and Haiti on its list of worst human trafficking offenders on Thursday, drawing guarded praise from some human rights groups following criticism that last year’s State Department report was politicized.
While more than two dozen countries were downgraded in the closely watched Trafficking in Persons (TIP) report, Thailand was removed from the bottom rung despite what the State Department described as “widespread forced labour” in the country’s vital seafood industry.
Other nations demoted to the lowest ranking were Turkmenistan, Djibouti, Papua New Guinea and Suriname.
But the Philippines, a key US ally widely known for its thriving sex industry, was moved up to the top tier — the same level as countries like the United States and Germany — even though the report said sex trafficking there was still a “significant problem.”
Despite that, some human rights groups especially welcomed downgrades for Burma and Uzbekistan, strategically important US partners, and said those decisions may reflect an effort to restore credibility to the annual report, which grades countries in the fight against modern-day slavery.
Critics had contended that politics trumped human rights in some of last year’s key ranking decisions.
“On the whole, this year’s trafficking report accurately reflects and critiques the record of countries around the world in addressing human trafficking and forced labor, unlike the report issued last year, which was marred by strong indications of political interference,” said Sarah Margon, Washington director for Human Rights Watch.
But she also said Thailand’s upgrade, which the report linked to legal reforms and increased prosecutions, was “problematic.” Still, it could smooth US relations with the military-run government at a time when Washington seeks Southeast Asian unity against China in the South China Sea.
The State Department demoted Uzbekistan to the bottom ranking just a year after giving a higher rating to the central Asian country, where state-orchestrated forced labor underpins its vital cotton industry. Turkmenistan’s downgrade was also based on its policy of forcing citizens to work the cotton fields.
“The Uzbek case appears to signal that they’re making the ranking decisions based more on the situation on the ground rather than other factors,” said Matthew Fischer-Daly, coordinator for the Cotton Campaign advocacy coalition.
Criticism of Malaysia, Thai rankings
But the Alliance to End Slavery and Trafficking expressed disappointment that the report “failed to fix last year’s politically motivated upgrade of Malaysia and unjustifiably upgraded Thailand.”
Secretary of State John Kerry said ranking decisions were not influenced by politics or other factors. “There are some tough calls. In the end they come down to an element of discretion, but not much,” he said.
A Reuters investigation published in August found that senior diplomats repeatedly overruled the State Department’s anti-trafficking unit and inflated the grades of 14 strategically important countries. The State Department denied any political considerations but US lawmakers raised questions about the report’s credibility and called for reforms.
US Senator Bob Menendez, expressing dismay over Malaysia and Cuba retaining higher rankings, vowed to introduce legislation to address “flaws” in the ranking process — a threat he issued last year but which has yet to translate into action.
The downgrade for Burma appeared aimed at prodding the country’s new democratically elected government, headed by Nobel Peace Prize winner Aung San Suu Kyi, and its still-powerful military to further curb use of child soldiers and forced labour.
It was also meant to underscore US concern about continued persecution of the Rohingya Muslim minority in the Buddhist-majority nation. The reprimand came despite US efforts to court Burma to help counteract China’s rise in the region.
The Thai embassy in Washington welcomed the report, saying it “recognizes the progress and significant efforts made by Thailand in the fight against human trafficking.”
In addition, the report highlighted the Syria refugee crisis and reiterated that almost all sides in the civil war there, including government forces as well as US-backed Syrian Kurdish YPG fighters, were recruiting child soldiers.
The report sorts countries into four categories: Tier 1 for nations that meet minimum US standards; Tier 2 for those that are making significant efforts to do so; Tier 2 “Watch List” for those that deserve special scrutiny; and Tier 3 for countries that fail to fully comply with the minimum US standards and are not making significant efforts to do so.
A Tier 3 rating can trigger sanctions, but US presidents frequently waive such action.