Phuketwan journalists cleared on all charges

Phuketwan journalists cleared on all charges

A court on the Thai island of Phuket cleared two journalists on Tuesday of defaming the Thai navy and other related charges in a report they published in 2013 on the trafficking of Muslim minority Rohingya people from Burma.

Speaking to DVB after the verdict, Alan Morison, the editor of the Phuketwan news website at the centre of the case, said, “We’re delighted for media freedom and for the cause of the Rohingya boatpeople. Thai justice has triumphed.

“It should be the start of a more mature relationship between the military and the media. We hope it does some good too in Burma for the Rohingya, who need tolerance and understanding,” the Australian added.

The high-profile case was one of a number brought by authorities under Thailand’s harsh defamation and cyber-crime laws that have drawn criticism from rights groups concerned about curbs on freedom of speech in the military-run country.

File photo of Rohingya boat people in the Andaman. (Reuters screenshot)
File photo of Rohingya boat people in the Andaman. (Reuters screenshot)

The complaint against Morison and his colleague, Thai national Chutima Sidasathian, was filed by a naval officer based in Phuket.

The two journalists faced up to two years in prison on the defamation charges and five years for offences under Thailand’s Computer Crimes Act.

The judge at the criminal court in Phuket ruled the two not guilty on all counts in a verdict that took less than 15 minutes to read.

“I feel fantastic, the bad dream has ended,” Morison said.

Morison and Chutima smiled, embraced and shook hands with people in the packed courtroom after the judge acquitted them on the grounds their report did not constitute defamation or threaten national security.

“The news we covered was of public interest,” said Chutima. “There was no need for us to self-censor.”

The journalists are based in Phuket, a holiday island off southern Thailand’s Indian Ocean coast, and published the report for the Phuketwan news website.

The Phuketwan report contained excerpts from a Reuters Special Report that detailed how some Thai naval security forces worked with people smugglers to profit from the exodus.

In reading the verdict, Judge Chaipawat Chaya-anandpat said the navy’s defamation complaint was not relevant to the section of the Computer Crimes Act it was filed under and the original story was accurate.

“The news presented by Reuters news agency does not appear to be false or constitute to causing panic or affecting national security,” he said.

A Thai navy spokesman declined to comment on Tuesday.

The officer who filed the complaint against Phuketwan for the July 2013 story also filed a criminal complaint against Reuters reporters Jason Szep and Stuart Grudgings, alleging violations of the Computer Crimes Act.

Reuters has not been charged, company spokesman David Crundwell said on Tuesday.

“We are pleased at the court’s verdict in the case today as Reuters wholeheartedly supports the principles of a free press, and the imperative of journalists across the world to publish independent and reliable news,” Crundwell said in an emailed response to questions.

Reuters strongly objects to the use of criminal laws anywhere in the world to attempt to punish journalists for the important and valuable work that they do.”

Szep and another Reuters journalist, Andrew R.C. Marshall, won a Pulitzer prize in 2014 for a year-long series of stories on the Rohingya written from Burma, Thailand and Malaysia.

[related]

Asked about whether he believed today’s verdict would have an impact on the continuation of human trafficking in the region, Morison told DVB: “Whether or not Phuketwan continues, we hope the Rohingya are treated with compassion and justice. ASEAN has to accept that ethnic cleansing is not part of the region’s future.

“Thailand has been helping Burma to get rid of its Rohingya problem. Both countries have to recognise that the ‘export the boatpeople’ experiment is over.”

Thailand this year cracked down on the people smugglers and traffickers who preyed on the Rohingya as they fled poverty and persecution in Burma [officially known as Myanmar] through neighbouring Thailand.

Thai authorities have indicted 72 people, including 15 state officials, over suspected links to trafficking in what police said was their biggest investigation of people smuggling.

Most of the estimated 1.1 million Rohingya in Burma live in the western Arakan State. Tens of thousands have fled the region by boat since 2012, after violent clashes with ethnic Arakanese Buddhists killed hundreds of people and displaced 140,000.

Asked by DVB whether he, Chutima and the Phuketwan website could continue operating in Phuket, Morison said, “We’re not really sure about our futures. We’d like the reporting of the plight of the Rohingya to continue. We’d like the laws that repress media freedom in Thailand to be killed. We may have a small part to play, but we hope others are also now more aware and will act to improve human rights and media freedom for all.”

 

Leave a reply